← All posts

What makes clinical event adjudication audit-ready

When a clinical events committee classifies an adverse event, or a committee decides whether a protocol deviation removes a subject from the per-protocol analysis, that decision can affect the results of the trial. Eventually someone may ask how it was made: a sponsor's quality team, an auditor, or a regulator reviewing the submission.

An audit-ready adjudication process is one where that question has a short, complete answer. Each decision can be traced back to who made it, what they looked at, what criteria they applied, and how any disagreement was resolved.

In practice, that comes down to a handful of habits.

1. Reviewers decide independently first

The value of a committee comes from independent expert judgment. If reviewers can see each other's answers before they submit their own, or if the sponsor's view is visible on the review screen, that independence is hard to show afterward.

A defensible process has each reviewer assess the case on their own, against the same source materials, before any comparison happens. Consensus is checked after the independent determinations are in. Sponsor dashboards show progress, not influence.

2. Every reviewer works from the same evidence

Disagreements are often less about clinical judgment than about evidence: one reviewer saw an updated CRF page and another didn't, or one had the imaging and another worked from a narrative summary.

Collecting the dossier, CRF pages, and images in one place, and making them view-only so nothing can be altered or quietly downloaded and edited, means every determination rests on the same record. When sites later change source data, the updated case should come back clearly flagged, with a summary of exactly what changed.

3. The form enforces the charter

The committee charter defines what reviewers must decide and how. A structured adjudication form is where that charter becomes concrete:

  • the event definitions and classification options match the charter's wording;
  • required fields can't be skipped, including a written rationale;
  • reviewers only see criteria the sponsor has designated as needing medical judgment, while objective, data-driven criteria stay out of the way.

Free-text emails and spreadsheets make it easy to leave a field blank or answer a slightly different question. A form that enforces the charter makes consistency the default.

4. Disagreement follows a rule, not a conversation

Committees will disagree, and that is healthy. What matters is that the path from disagreement to a final answer is defined in advance and applied the same way every time.

A common pattern is two independent reviewers per case. If they agree, the case is final. If they disagree, a third reviewer acts as tiebreaker. If there is still no consensus, or a reviewer asks for discussion, the case goes to the full committee, where a quorum decides and the outcome is recorded as the meeting determination.

When routing is automatic, nobody has to remember the rule, and the record shows it was followed.

5. The trail is complete, and final means final

Audit readiness is ultimately about the record. Every action, from opening a dossier to submitting a determination to recording a committee decision, should be attributed to a named person and timestamped. Once a determination is submitted, it should be locked.

Before data are exported for analysis, an administrator should check for incomplete or inconsistent entries. After the final export, the record should be closed to new entries and deletions, and any later review should happen in a fresh copy rather than by editing history.

Putting it together

None of these habits is complicated on its own. The difficulty is applying all of them consistently across hundreds of events, several reviewers, and the length of a trial, while keeping the workload manageable for busy clinicians.

That is the problem we built Reviewr™ to solve: structured, charter-driven forms, automatic consensus and tiebreak routing, view-only source materials, and an audit trail with records locked on submission, configured to each study's protocol.

If you are planning a CEC or DSMB and want to talk through how your adjudication process will hold up, get in touch.

Planning a CEC or DSMB?

Contact us